1. People aspects of structural change in the People’s Republic of ChinaJune 21, 20012001年6月21日中国进行企业结构调整过程中的人员与激励管理
2. The business of business is business企业重在经营
- Milton FriedmanTo get rich is glorious发展才是硬道理
- Deng XiaoPing邓小平The great object of the political economy of every country, is to increase the riches and power of that country.各国政治经济体制的宗旨在于增加该国的财富与实力。
- Adam Smith
3. Agenda议程Global overview of privatization lessons全球企业市场化经验概述
Role of government in transition政府部门在过渡过程中所发挥的作用
Executives and Leadership对高层经理与领导者的激励与约束机制
Long-term Incentives pre-listing公司上市前的长期奖励
Compensation Data薪酬数据
What does it all tell us?结论
4. Lessons from overseas来自海外的经验US:美国:
the world’s most advanced, competitive economy - most economic freedom全球最发达、最富竞争力的经济体制:经济自由度最大
virtually no experience with privatization实际上缺乏企业股份化经验
Japan:日本:
culturally, the most similar advanced economy to Japan, but stalled in the modern economy. New hope from market reforms从文化的维度而言,最类似于日本的发达经济,但日本目前处于停滞不前的状态。市场变革带来新的希望
5. Lessons from overseas来自海外的经验Western Europe:西欧:
Privatization everywhere, led by UK在英国的带动下,各地都在进行股份化
Different tradition regarding employment截然不同的人员聘用传统
If you create monopolies, not much changes若进行垄断,不会出现过多的变革
Competition creates wealth竞争创造财富
Need to break up old industries to create competition需要打破原有的行业格局,促进竞争
Workforces reduced, but society richer人员减少,但社会更加富足
7. Privatization Transition - UK Water股份化过渡 - UK WaterLongest most recent experience (15+yrs)最长、最新的经验(15年以上)
Gradual listings for many companies许多公司逐步上市
previous managers put in charge原有的经理负责进行管理
carefully regulated markets仔细进行市场规约
initial compensation increase followed by move to market pay遵照市场行情来提供最初的加薪
Few “golden shares” (BP, VSEL)极少“黄金股票”(BP,VSEL)
8. Privatization Transition - UK Water股份化过渡 - UK WaterProblems with several industries许多行业所面临的问题
regulated monopolies规约垄断
higher pay for executives, but little behaviour change lower down高层经理薪酬水准提高,但行为变革幅度却有所下降
competition is key竞争是关键
electric/water industries being re-organized for capital reasons: separating supply from distribution鉴于资本方面的原因,对电力/水力行业进行调整:供应与配送分离
9. Privatization Transition - UK Water股份化过渡 - UK WaterOriginally single operation, run regionally最初为单一型地区运营
Employed 100,000员工总数达10万人
Controlled supply, distribution, customer interface, sewerage disposal控制供应、配送、客户关系及污水处理部门
Regional authorities privatized, but remained monopolies.地区权限市场化,但仍存在垄断
Some companies bought by foreigners某些公司为外资所收购
10. Privatization Transition - UK Water股份化过渡 - UK WaterGovernment body (OFWAT) set up to regulate, make standards, guarantee prices, etc通过设立政府机构(OFWAT)来进行调控、制定标准和稳定价格等工作
Water companies operated better, but no substantial change, because monopolies still existedWater公司运作情况有所好转,但因仍存在着垄断,并未出现实质性的变化
Government-sponsored restructuring will leave supply separate from distribution, separate from billings政府部门所发起的企业结构调整工作将导致供应与配送、核算部门分离
11. Privatization Transition - UK Water股份化过渡 - UK WaterSupply companies will supply only供应公司将仅仅供应
better capital structure优化资本结构
limits monopoly限制垄断
Distribution and customer interface配送与客户关系部门
Contracted - open to competition商定 - 公开竞争
Now 40,000 employees and falling现有40,000名员工,并正在有所下降
Consumers, producers and government happy客户、生产方和政府均比较满意
12. China is the same…but China is different!中国亦如此…但有其独特之处!Some differences with US:与美国所存在的一些差异 - 以下是美国市场所表现的特点:
Very fluid, competitive labor market充满活力、富有竞争力的人才市场
Highly educated, confident workforce高学历、充满自信的人才队伍
Work is a contract between equals在平等的基础上签署工作合同
Very low unionization很少进行联合
Few government-owned enterprises极少存在国有企业
Tradition of wide stock ownership for investment广义的股票投资所有权传统
Strong tradition for rule of law良好的法律传统
Happiness with mix of market and government regulation乐于将市场与政府规章相匹配
13. The real issue is change真正的问题源于变革Minor change细微变革
Feels easy感觉容易
Retains gov’t control保留政府控制
Low prices for assets资产价格较低Major Change重大变革
Difficult艰难
Loses gov’t control失去政府控制
High prices代价较高How far, and how fast?跨度?速度?
14. Lesson learned in the US来自美国的经验Three conditions for effective markets:有效的市场所需具备的三个条件:
information on companies and markets freely available公司和市场自由运作方面的信息
liquidity - ability to buy and sell easily流通性 - 能够比较容易地进行购买和出售
one set of rules for all一套通用的规则
treat everyone the same一视同仁
minimize discretion最大限度地减少区别
15. The Talent Solution人才解决方案Improving Business Results
through People …通过人员来改善经营结果...Business
Results经营结果Business
Strategy经营战略People
Requirements人员要求Employee
Needs员工需求People Practices, Policies,
Programs人员方案、政策、计划Balanced
Measurement均衡评估法Successful private sector companies manage for value成功的私营公司的价值管理模式Business
Process经营程序People/HR Strategy人员/人力资源战略
Employment Relationship聘用关系
16. The Talent Solution人才解决方案Every company is different因公司而异
17. The Talent Solution人才解决方案Are they creating the right environment where the right people want to come, stay, and contribute?他们是否正在营造恰当的工作环境,以便吸引恰当的人才加盟、留用并作出积极贡献?Can they point to progress and results from working on these issues?他们能否通过解决这些问题来取得进步并实现预期结果?Businesses in all sectors face the same issues各行各业面临着同样的问题Do they have the right people doing the right things to meet their goals?
为实现目标,他们是否任命恰当的人员来完成恰当的工作?
18. The Talent Solution人才解决方案 People
Management人员管理 Staffing (the right people)人员配置(恰当的人员)Organizing (the right roles)组织(合理的角色及职责分)Developing (the right skills)发展(恰当的技能)Performing (the right outcomes)绩效管理(合理的结果)Rewarding (the right incentives)全面薪酬(合理的回报)People
Practices, Policies,
Programs人员
方案、政策、计划A closer look at how people create value in a business近观人员为企业创造价值的模式
19. Organizing组织Structure is a consequence of strategy组织结构即是战略成果
Board of Directors董事会
Representation of ALL shareholders代表所有股东
Oversight of management监督管理人员
Committee system委员会系统
Management管理层
Strategy and execution战略与实施
Outsourcing外包
21. Staffing人员配置Boards of Directors董事会成员
what kinds of people?人员类型?
understand business strategy理解经营战略
connections to other industries, experience与其它行业相关、经验
careful over representation of a particular group谨慎代表某个特定的小组
22. Staffing人员配置Management管理
Big decision - will set the stage for years to come重大决策 - 为将来奠定基础
Are today’s incumbents the right people?当前的任职者是否称职?
Managers need to be able to take decisions经理们需要具备相应的决策力
Must be free from short-term government interference, but must lose job security as a cadre必须免受政府的短期干预,但管理者失去工作保障
23. Performing绩效管理Common understanding of organizational goals and priorities针对组织目标与重点达成共识
Where are we going?我们有何目标?Clear expectations for individual and group contributions明确对个人和小组贡献的期望
What part do I play?我需要发挥什么作用?Capability built through feedback and learning通过反馈和学习来培养能力
How do we gain commitment from employees?我们如何获取员工承诺?Commitment based on meaningful work and rewards基于合理的工作任务与薪酬基础之上的承诺
What will it take?需要哪些投入?Source: 1994-6 research by Hewitt Associates出自:翰威特咨询有限公司1994-1996年度调查结果。
24. Developing发展Key for all businesses对所有企业而言至关重要
Fits Chinese culture and desires适合于中国文化和期望
Current skill levels for operation in a market are low现有的运营技能在市场中处于偏低水准
Capitalism “101” for directors and managers针对总监和经理们的“101”资本主义制度
Differing needs for each enterprise各企业的不同需求
25. Rewarding全面薪酬Does compensation motivate people?薪酬能否激励员工?
Needs careful design需要进行仔细设计
Alignment with strategy is crucial关键在于遵照公司战略
“You get what you pay for”您已取得应有绩效
Next pages show some thoughts on stock options, long-term incentives pre-IPO and some market data for executives…...下文中将介绍有关股权激励及公司上市前高层经理长期奖励的一些观点和市场数据…...
26. Stock Options - Conditions for success有效实施股权激励所必须具备的条件:Must be:
strong corporate governance framework
完善的公司治理结构
clear taxation system
健全的税收体系和制度
clear rules for whether companies can use Treasury stock or must buy stock
有关股票来源问题有明确的规定(公司可利用库存股票或回购股票)
27. Stock Options - Conditions for success有效实施股权激励所必须具备的条件:The government role is low and decisions must be left to the market
政府只做它应该做的事,决定权交给市场
Publicity for investors
完善的信息披露
Rules against insider trading
有关内部交易的制约机制
28. Long-term incentives - pre-listing长期奖励 - 上市前Pre-listing - usually no stock on which to offer options上市前 - 通常没有可以提供期权的股票
Three other choices:其它三种选择:
cash plan - absolute performance现金计划 - 绝对绩效
cash plan - relative performance现金计划 - 相对绩效
phantom stock plan虚拟股票计划
29. Long-term incentives - pre-listing长期奖励 - 上市前Cash plan - absolute performance现金计划:绝对绩效
Simplest solution: decide upon key goal(s) and reward management for achieving it/them - 2 or 3 year plan最简单的方案:确定以关键经营目标的实现为基点的薪酬管理方案 - 2/3年激励计划
Difficulty is goal-setting process, because goals may appear easy/tough in retrospect目标设定程序较难,因为在期末审核时,目标或许似乎较容易/艰难
Needs judgement - function of Board需要加以判断 - 是董事会的职能
30. Long-term incentives - pre-listing长期奖励 - 上市前Cash-plan - relative performance现金计划:相对绩效
Measures most often used: Total Shareholder Return, growth, Return on Equity最常见的评估标准:总体股东投资回报、增长、股权收益
Only works for public companies where published data is reliable仅适用于那些公布可靠数据的非上市公司
31. Long-term incentives - pre-listing长期奖励 - 上市前Phantom Stock Plan虚拟股票计划
(1) Assume company divided into stock假设公司实行股份制
Divide earnings by # stock units = EPS营业收益除以股票单位数量=每股收益
Multiply EPS by market P/E ratio = stock price用市盈率(P/E) 乘以每股收益=股票价格
(2) Have the company valued by an independent firm由一家独立的机构来对该公司进行估价
32. Long-term incentives - pre-listing长期奖励 - 上市前Compensation influences management behavior薪酬影响管理行为
Does the plan need to be changed during the term because the situation has changed?在计划执行期间,若情况发生了变化,我们是否需要对该计划加以修改?
Will management “game” the system and act in its own interest to the detriment of the company?管理人员是否将运用该系统来谋私利、损害公司利益?
These are questions that require a Board这些问题需要由董事会来进行监控
33. Compensation data薪酬数据Compensation data for 2000 taken from Hewitt databases in US, Europe and Japan摘自翰威特咨询公司设在美国、欧洲和日本的数据库中的2000年度薪酬数据
several countries combined for Europe欧洲许多国家的综合数据
four sizes of company in US四种规模的美国公司
stock options valued using Black-Scholes methodology运用Black-Scholes方法所估价的股票期权
Benefits and perquisites valued as annual equivalents对福利与特殊津贴进行年度定价
34. Compensation data - US薪酬数据 - 美国Companies Greater than 10 Billion规模100亿美元以上的公司Top Executives高层经理17%11%6%65%1%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴Total: US$2,675k总计:2675K美元
35. Compensation data - US薪酬数据 - 美国Companies Greater than 10 Billion规模在100亿美元以上的公司Senior Management Positions高层管理人员34%12%10%43%1%Total: US$548k总计:548K美元Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
36. Compensation data - US薪酬数据 - 美国Companies Greater than 10 Billion规模在100亿美元以上的公司Middle Management Positions中层管理人员51%10%11%27%1%Total: US$229k总计:229K美元Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
37. Compensation data - US薪酬数据 - 美国Companies Greater than 10 Billion规模在100亿美元以上的公司Professional Positions专业人员72%5%17%6%0%Total: US$81k总计:81K美元Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
38. Compensation data - Europe薪酬数据 - 欧洲Top Executives高层经理49%13%11%18%9%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
39. Compensation data - Europe薪酬数据 - 欧洲Senior Management高层管理人员58%11%10%10%11%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
40. Compensation data - Europe薪酬数据 - 欧洲Middle Management中层管理人员68%6%10%3%13%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
41. Compensation data - Europe薪酬数据Professional Positions专业人员75%5%9%1%10%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
42. Compensation data - Japan all industry薪酬数据 - 日本所有行业Top Executives高层经理64%31%3%2%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
43. Compensation data - Japan Hi-tech薪酬数据 - 日本高科技行业Top Executives高层经理70%13%2%15%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
44. Compensation data - Japan all industry薪酬数据 - 日本所有行业Senior Managers高层管理人员64%25%11%0%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
45. Compensation data - Japan all industry薪酬数据 - 日本所有行业Middle Managers中层管理人员57%26%17%0%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
46. Compensation data - Japan all industry薪酬数据 - 日本所有行业Professional Positions专业人员67%25%8%0%Base Salary基本工资Bonus奖金Benefits福利LTI长期奖励Perks特殊津贴
48. Total compensation differences - US$全面薪酬差异 - 美元050000010000001500000200000025000003000000Execs高层经理Sr Mgmt高层管理人员Mid Mgmt中层管理人员Profess‘l专业人员>$10bn100亿美元以上>$5bn50亿美元以上>$2.5bn25亿美元以上>$1bn10亿美元以上<$1bn10亿美元以下
49. Compensation data - Learnings薪酬数据 - 结论Markets are messy!市场数据不规范!
Has anyone got it right? No!是否有任何人得出正确答案?没有!
Americans concerned at governance and issues over executive pay美国关注高层经理薪酬的管理和相关问题
Japanese economy stalled, because needed change cannot occur日本经济停滞不前,因为尚未进行必要的变革
Egalitarianism in Europe欧洲的平等主义
50. Summary总结Finance财务
Technology技术
People人员
The only long-term sustainable competitive advantage is from people唯一的长期性、持久性竞争优势在于“人”